Ratings and Reviews

Sheila is an amazing attorney! She handled my 2 year old daughter’s case after she was attacked by a dog leaving her with many scars. She was able to settle her case with two different insurance companies in just 6 months after the incident. I highly recommend Sheila for her knowledge, professionalism to get the best possible outcome in taking care of the people she’s representing. She shows so much compassion and puts in endless hours to ensure her clients are well taken care of! Thank you Sheila and the staff at Paige Donnelly Law office, my family is eternally grateful for everyone that handled Kaci’s case.
-Katie Gladney

If you are looking for a relentlessly hard working, compassionate and respectful Law Office to work with, Look no further than Sheila & the Paige Donnelly Law Group. – Sheila is one of the best around! Sheila had represented me and my case after I was in a very bad car accident. The auto accident had a very big impact on my life and day to day tasks which left me feeling like I had no-one to turn to for help. After I had met with Sheila and the Paige Donnelly Law Firm I knew immediately that I had a very professional & knowledgeable group to help me navigate through one of the hardest times in my life. I cannot stress how highly I recommend Sheila & the Paige Donnelly Law Firm. Sheila was incredibly understanding of my concerns & showed a very deep level of compassion & respect to what I was going through. I want to give a huge Thank you Sheila and the Paige Donnelly Law office team. I am forever grateful for all the help and support your team provided throughout my experience working with you all.
-Sam Illgen

I am VERY pleased with my recent settlement! Paige Donnelly and his entire team exceeded all expectations with their compassionate and reliable handling of my case. They always responded quickly to my phone or email communications plus were extremely efficient and friendly throughout the entire process. Support staff would make me feel special going out of their way to meet me. Always sensitive to my needs, they were a calming presence putting my concerns at ease.

The stars were in line when I got connected to this firm!⭐ They resolved an unfortunate situation. I can’t thank them enough! I HIGHLY recommend Paige J. Donnelly, Ltd.!
-G T

It was a true pleasure working with Sheila Donnelly. Immediately, I knew I was in competent hands. Sheila is a compassionate, experienced, wise, attentive, honorable attorney who provides quality work. She responded promptly to issues as they arose. Sheila was most generous with her time in explaining and guiding me through a situation that was completely unfamiliar to me. Her expert advice and effective approach resulted in problem resolution without prolonged litigation. I am grateful to have worked with such a kind, experienced and talented attorney.
-Mary Ann Fenlon

Our first experience with this firm was with Debbie, from start to the end she has always been there to help when needed. Sheila then advised us through out our case and her compassion and patients with us made the whole experience as bearable as possible. We are satisfied the outcome. We would recommend Sheila to anyone that needed a good experienced law firm.
-David Pederson

Our experience with Mr. Paige Donnelly thoroughly exceeded our expectations for an accident we were involved in. He treated us with care and dignity in an ethical manner throughout the entire process. Paige is an kind attorney and worked very hard to represent us. His stellar professional knowledge is nothing less than excellent! We would recommend him and his entire law firm to anyone seeking counsel. A huge thank you to all involved in our case!
-Rock Tierney

I was involved in a motor vehicle collision in April 2018. The driver of the other car was at fault and my right ankle/leg was broken in multiple places requiring two surgeries, and possibly others in the future. I was referred to Sheila Donnelly-Coyne by a very close friend and from day one Sheila and her entire team exceeded my expectations. My case took over 4 years before settling (a lot was pushed back to due covid) and everybody was so courteous over those years. We ended up setting a court date but settled for an amount that we agreed was fair 10 days before the scheduled trial date. Sheila isn’t afraid to fight for the best possible outcome for you and I will certainly recommend her to anyone!
-Rachel Solosky

After the initial shock and pain of a traumatic accident you soon realize you need a guide to get you through the legal process, I was lucky to have found Sheila, she educated me on the complexity of the law and was a true guide on my journey too recovery and resolution of my claim. Sheila educated me on what to expect, what the law allows and what the opposition was doing. In short, I got the settlement I wanted and NO surprise’s, I like that. You can count on Sheila and Jessica to guide you through the process with professionalism and grace. They are a team that truly cares about you. I highly recommend Sheila and Jessica to help guide you in your road to recovery.
-Boro Robo

When we needed help navigating personal injury, Sheila Donnelly and her team of lawyers, paralegals and investigators were up to the task. They handled all aspects from the medical and car insurance companies, medical billing, the many claims adjusters, employment issues for lost time and wages. Sheila and her team worked tirelessly pressuring the other parties and in the end achieved the results we wanted. If we are ever in this position again, they are the firm we will turn to.
-B Hergott

At first we hesitated if Mr. Donnelly was the right attorney for our case. Thankfully we listened to our hearts by taking the chance. We were very satisfied with Mr. Donnelly and his law firm with the outcome of our cases. What Mr. Donnelly and his law firm done for us exceeded our expectation! Thank you so much Paige Donnelly. You and your law firm are the best!! I would highly recommend them.
-Lyndah Vagh

I was injured in a motor vehicle accident in Minnesota, and hired Sheila Donnelly-Coyne after several friends and family members highly recommended that I do so. Several months later I was injured in another motor vehicle accident involving a semi, and the accident occurred in Florida, I again hired Sheila because I was pleased with the representation I was already receiving. One case was settled and the other case proceeded to trial. I was impressed with Sheila’s compassion, knowledge, and professionalism, and I was also impressed with the entire team at Paige J. Donnelly, Ltd. If you need to hire an attorney, especially if you are involved in a collision involving a semi, I highly recommend Sheila.
-Joe Pederson

This company and its employees are excellent at letting their customers know what is going on with their case so they can make the most knowledgeable decisions for themselves and their case. Very comprehensive. Very hard working. All together I’ve had an excellent experience with Paige Donelley’s firm and specifically Douglas Scheel.
-Sammy S

Paige Donnelly law firm worked diligently to get the best outcome for me. They were knowledgeable, personable and professional. A joy to work with. I would definitely recommend them to anyone in need of a personal injury attorney.
-Heather Feroni

Sheila was so helpful. She supported me through some really traumatic things that happened to me. Caring and compassionate. I would recommend her to anyone I know that needs legal help. She’s awesome!
-Debra Jaqua

I was very satisfied with how my attorney and staff working with him handled my case. Mark Perron did an excellent job for me and I’m very grateful and would recommend Paige Donnelly to friends and family.
-James Grimes

I was a mess after my accident. I suffered a traumatic brain injury. Mr. Donnelly was so kind, professional and kept me or my husband in the loop. I felt very very supported by the entire staff. Mr. Donnelly personifies integrity. I would recommend him or any of the other attorneys on staff. Thank you Thank you Thank you Mr. Donnelly!
-Carrie

Wonderful firm, professional and fantastic people who truly care about their clients. A special shout out and Thank You to Mark Perron who promptly replied to and patiently answered my questions. Would not hesitate to work with this firm for personal injury and Mark specifically regarding Estate Law.
-Roberta Norden

Mr. Donnelly is a very experienced Attorney. He and his team have taken on many cases with ultimate results!! I am so pleased to have had him work on my case.
-Charlotte Guthmiller

I highly recommend this law firm! Everything the law firm and Sheila has done for me have been above and beyond! They truly care for their clients and any questions or concerns are answered with a fast responsive time! I will absolutely refer them to anybody in need!
-Samantha Williams